THE COLLECTOR: ICONS INTERVIEW with Marcus Dunstan & Patrick Melton
July 31, 2009
On July 31st, THE COLLECTOR, the directorial debut of Marcus Dunstan will hit select theaters across the country. And as a genre fan you should take note. This indie flick was written by Dunstan with Patrick Melton, the duo whom have scripted not only the FEAST trilogy, but also SAW IV, SAW V and SAW VI. (They’ve just been tapped to write SAW VII) We got the chance to chat with them about all of the above, including the humble beginnings of THE COLLECTOR prior to the movie’s premiere last night in Hollywood. Read on for our exclusive chat with Marcus Dunstan and Patrick Melton!
Robg.: Where did the story for THE COLLECTOR come chronologically for you guys? Was this something you wrote after FEAST but before SAW IV?
Marcus Dunstan (Director, Writer): This was actually written before FEAST!
Patrick Melton (Writer): This started as a short film – to go way back, when I was in film school, I had to come up with ideas for short scripts for this Kodak endowment thing, where Kodak gave LMU all this money to make a short film and so Marcus and I had written “ROLLED BONES”, which was the first script before FEAST in 1999. And so we brainstormed together and we came up with this short script and it’s called THIEF, what if a thief broke into the house of a serial killer? We wrote the script and it didn’t get made for that thing, but afterwords, we decided let’s make this on our own & Marcus wanted to direct it. It was going to be a 10 minute short, but then we won PROJECT GREENLIGHT. So then it went on hiatus.
Robg.: Well, you guys were busy for a couple of years after that! (Laughs)
Patrick Melton: Right after (the first) SAW came out, everybody wanted that million dollar idea. Like a horror movie that you could make for under a million dollars, and you can make it in a contained location with a high concept. We had this idea and we ended up pitching it in a meeting to these guys who ended up producing this. They bought it in the room, with the agreement that Marcus would direct it. We finished the script, but the problem was the company said they didn’t have enough money so they were going to go halves with another company. Marcus didn’t have an appropriate reel so we couldn’t sell him as a director. So the company gave us $5000 to shoot the trailer to the movie, which would be stylized to show off Marcus as a director. So we did that. All the Gulager’s helped, Jon Gulager shot it. Clu Gulager was in it, Diane Goldner was in it, Tom (Gulager) was in it. It came out really good, and we started taking meetings showing people the trailer along with the script. Bob Weinstein ended up seeing it, watched the trailer, closed the door to his office and said “You’re not leaving this office until I get this movie.” So we sold it to him. A year or so later, we started shooting in Streetport, Louisiana with Marcus directing and we finished it. Edited it for about a year and then they watched it. (Marcus starts laughing) And said, “We love it! But… we don’t have any money.” Because all their money was in HALLOWEEN 2 and INGLOURIOUS BASTERDS…
Robg.: (Sarcastically) Those pesky movies that no one’s going to see!
Patrick Melton: Right! So we said, “What if we bought it back?” And they said sure, as long as you give us what we spent for it then sure. Mickey Liddell watched it, really liked it, bought it back and here we are.
Robg.: Now let me ask you – I know very little about the movie beyond the initial premise. And you had this story for a while, but the general misconception is obviously – you guys have done the SAW sequels and THE COLLECTOR has “traps” in it. So, what can you say to genre fans that don’t know anything about the movie? How is this different from what we’ve seen in SAW IV, SAW V or SAW VI?
Marcus Dunstan: The difference between this and a SAW film is we’re coming from a point of a thriller intersecting with a horror movie. SAW has always taken place within the horror realm and has embraced that. Whereas we wanted to take James Caan from THIEF and have him accidentally break into The Tooth Fairy’s house from MANHUNTER. (Both Michael Mann movies, by the way!) Tactics to catch a cat burglar in your home, if you’re not going mano y mano from scene 1, it involved setting up some kind of snare. Perhaps setting up some kind of compromising position for that thief to have to endure. So we kept this as close to the vest and what you can really make from anything already in your home as possible. These things, if they are implements used in the movie, we built them ourselves in the living room. If you see razor blades? I cut my fingers on them for real to make sure they worked. And it’s just based on very intimate fears, things that are around your home, because we didn’t want this to be specific elaborate traps at all. We’re trying to create a villain that is the land equivalent of a shark. If you go into the water, a shark might get you. If you’re on land, you’re on this killer’s territory and everyone’s vulnerable.
Patrick Melton: The big difference too is I think the tone is very different. The SAW movies are wonderful because they almost seem like you’re going into a different world with the heightened reality, while this one, we tried to keep it much more grounded with things that are in your house. Thing that can be put together quickly that aren’t sort of too fantastic.
Robg.: It’s kinda like Nancy at the end of A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREET. Rigging the booby traps!
Patrick Melton: (Laughs) That’s so funny you say that.
Marcus Dunstan: I gotta say one thing. You’ve got to stay through the credits on this one, because we’ve rewarded the person that does! A little something extra.
Robg.: In terms of the SAW movies, you guys have both gone on record saying that SAW VI is one of your favorites, and probably the best one you’ve done. It seems you guys went into SAW IV, V and VI with an overall story arc. Now you guys are doing SAW VII. So is it interesting, challenging or different to start from scratch with SAW 7? Or are you continuing some of the threads that appeared in your trilogy?
Marcus Dunstan: A lot of SAW IV and SAW V really hinged on SAW VI coming together. And the way 6 did, it completely recharged our batteries creatively. 6 recharged us and it gave us new ground which we hope to mine more horror from.
Patrick Melton: What we were really trying to do was, we finished 6 and we were done with 6 before we even started thinking about SAW 7 to be honest. 6 ends and we wanted to end that arc from 4, 5 and 6. Those three, 4, 5 and 6 all make sense tying the stuff from the first 3 as well. And it ends! You could leave SAW VI and say ok, I’m done, I’m happy, I’m completely fulfilled. Now, with 7 we’re definitely turning the page a bit. It’s a new chapter. But you’ll see, and we can talk more in depth when you see 6, but you can where it’s going to go, but there is definitely a closure at the end of 6 and with 7, it is the beginning of a new trilogy. It’s the third trilogy for the SAW films.
Robg.: Is there any criteria going into PART 7 either from Twisted or Lionsgate, or are you guys free to go whatever direction you want?
Marcus Dunstan: No, there’s always been a bible and a cannon and an ultimate end game for them, so we have to respect the rules that have been established, and we have to respect the tone. Other then that, it is earned. Earn the audience.
Robg.: You’re both writers, and now Marcus is directing, but you also made a fun little cameo in Adam Green’s Halloween short film THE TIFFANY PROBLEM. Any chance we’ll see you acting in front of the camera again soon?
Marcus Dunstan: (Laughs) Based on my appearance in front of that camera, I think I’m going to have to do a little changin’ before I make any more appearances! (Laughs)
Robg.: I seriously just want to thank you guys for FEAST. That first movie was probably one of my favorite genre pictures since EVIL DEAD 2: DEAD BY DAWN. Just the same kind of energy, so I’m always indebted to you guys for writing FEAST!
Marcus Dunstan: Aw, right on! We didn’t want to let any Gulager’s go untouched in THE COLLECTOR. Diane Goldner’s in it. Jon Gulager helped us with some shooting. Tom Gulager was the 2nd unit director when we were shooting for 24 hours a day! Clu Gulager recorded some beautiful narration for us. So everyone (from the family) is in this one.
Robg.: This is more of a fan to fan inquiry. HELLRAISER is up next to be “rebooted” and there have been several writers brought in and you guys were amongst the bunch to take a crack at it. What was your take on it, and what’s made this new HELLRAISER so difficult to crank?
Marcus Dunstan: The treatment for it was beautiful, and what it did was… it just gave scale to what was only hinted at in the darkness and the shadows of the first entry. We didn’t want to go back and repeat that story if at all possible, because that first story was wonderfully told. So, it wanted to grab darkness and appreciate it much like a PAN’S LABYRINTH would. And Pinhead’s become more then just that ending guy that gives a few lines. He’s become a figure in horror cinema, so we wanted to respect that, and re-announce that and make it bigger. The problem with that first treatment? It was too darned expensive. It just was.
Patrick Melton: Our thing was – everyone knows Pinhead. You show Pinhead, people know exactly who he is, the average person – they may not know exactly which movie it is or they may not have seen a HELLRAISER, but they know him. We were trying to build up his backstory and make him a true supervillain. And so, a lot of the story had to do with fleshing out his backstory, which is revealed more in PART 2. We were combining elements of 1 and 2 and building up Pinhead as a bigger character. Because not only in his past life, but also in the time he’s spent in hell. Giving him an end game, an end goal, and making him much more active as opposed to just torturing people. I don’t know, it was just maybe too much minutia for Dimension. At the end of the day –
Marcus Dunstan: Sometimes when you’re a fan of a movie, you want to put a hell of a lot more in it then necessary. You want to see the dream version of it, when… maybe it needs to be sheer, severe and slick. And that might ultimately be the HELLRAISER that comes out. I don’t know.
Robg.: Besides THE COLLECTOR and SAW 7 obviously, what’s next? Anything you’re excited to tackle?
Marcus Dunstan: Well, I’d love to direct an adaptation of a graphic novel called DEAL WITH THE DEVIL by Mike Miller. It’s just a brilliant bad-ass plot and I think it would make one hell of a movie.
THE COLLECTOR is now playing!
Icons of Fright Archive
2024
2011
- Icons Of Fright presents Robg’s TOP 10 Horror Movies of 2011!
- FRIGHT EXCLUSIVE PIRATE COMMENTARY – HALLOWEEN 6: THE CURSE OF MICHAEL MYERS with writer Daniel Farrands
- FRIGHT INTERVIEW – Frank Henenlotter, Writer/Director of BASKET CASE
- TRICK ‘R TREAT Writer/Director Michael Dougherty’s Halloween Movie Picks!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Nick Principe, Chromeskull of LAID TO REST
2010
- Paul Solet in “Predator Mode” on the set of GRACE
- Adam Green & Paul Solet Talk In Fahkin Boston Accents (With subtitles kid!)
2009
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Glenn McQuaid
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Paul Solet, Writer Director of GRACE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Jordan Ladd From GRACE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: GRACE Producer Adam Green
- THE COLLECTOR: ICONS INTERVIEW with Marcus Dunstan & Patrick Melton
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Dave Parker, Director of THE HILLS RUN RED
- ORPHAN: ICONS INTERVIEWS!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer Director Rob Zombie on HALLOWEEN 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: THE BURROWERS Director JT Petty
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress / Producer Bobbi Sue Luther
- Rob Zombie’s HALLOWEEN 2 SET REPORT PART 4: ACTRESS SCOUT TAYLOR-COMPTON!
- Rob Zombie’s HALLOWEEN 2 SET REPORT PART 3: PRODUCER ANDY GOULD!
- Rob Zombie’s HALLOWEEN 2 SET REPORT PART 2: PRODUCER MALEK AKKAD!
- Rob Zombie’s HALLOWEEN 2 SET REPORT PART 1: FX ARTIST WAYNE TOTH!
- HYAENA GALLERY INTERVIEW: An Icons of Fright Video
- DARK DELICACIES INTERVIEW: An Icons of Fright Video
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor / Filmmaker William Butler
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Director Jeff Burr
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Oliver Robins From POLTERGEIST
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Derek Mears, Jason Voorhees From FRIDAY THE 13TH 2009
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Composer Joseph Bishara
2008
- TERRIFYING TOYS: An Icons Of Fright Video
- From The Set of GRACE: Adam Green Message To ICONS OF FRIGHT Readers
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Susan Montford, Director of WHILE SHE WAS OUT
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Horror Icon Bruce Campbell!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: THE GHOULIGANS!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Tomas Alfredson, Director of LET THE RIGHT ONE IN
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Zach Passero, Director of WICKED LAKE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Mick Garris
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Jeremy Kasten, Director of WIZARD OF GORE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Erika Smith
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Actor Joshua Nelson, Interview 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Tuesday Knight From A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREET 4: THE DREAM MASTER
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Brian O’Halloran From CLERKS, BRUTAL MASSACRE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director / Actor Larry Fessenden
- ICONS INTERVIEW: BRUTAL MASSACRE Writer / Director Stevan Mena
- FRIGHT EXCLUSIVE: The PSYCHO Reunion Panel, FANGORIA Weekend Of Horrors 2008
- ICONS INTERVIEW: John Russo, Writer of NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Eric Red
- FRIGHT EXCLUSIVE: The FRIGHT NIGHT Reunion Panel At FEAR FEST 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Troma Entertainment President Lloyd Kaufman
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Gina Philips From JEEPERS CREEPERS
- ICONS INTERVIEW: MR. MONSTER Creator Michael T. Gilbert
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Neil Marshall, Writer / Director of THE DESCENT
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor / Director Keith Gordon
- PROM NIGHT: Revisited
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Gunnar Hansen, Leatherface From THE TEXAS CHAIN SAW MASSACRE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Dick Durock From SWAMP THING
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actors Zachary Levi and Joel David Moore From SPIRAL
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor AJ Bowen From THE SIGNAL
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Charlie Benante, The Drummer of ANTHRAX
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Anessa Ramsey & Justin Welborn of THE SIGNAL
2007
- ICONS INTERVIEW: John Kassir, The Voice Of THE CRYPTKEEPER!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: FX Artist & Creature Performer Tom Woodruff Jr
- ICONS INTERVIEW: The Producers Of THE SHARK IS STILL WORKING
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Cinematographer Will Barrett
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker Jane Rose
- ICONS INTERVIEW: DRIFTWOOD Director Tim Sullivan, Interview 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Cerina Vincent From CABIN FEVER
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress & Scream Queen Tiffany Shepis
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Rolfe Kanefsky, Interview 2
- ICON INTERVIEW: Jim Mickle, Director of MULBERRY STREET
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Horror Host ELVIRA, Mistress Of The Dark!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Jeffrey Combs From RE-ANIMATOR
- ICONS INTERVIEW: WRONG TURN 2 Director Joe Lynch
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Erica Leerhsen From WRONG TURN 2, TEXAS CHAINSAW
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Zelda Rubinstein From POLTERGEIST
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Paul Ehlers, “Madman Marz” From MADMAN!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Joel David Moore From HATCHET
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Tamara Feldman From HATCHET
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Mercedes McNab From HATCHET
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Deon Richmond From HATCHET, SCREAM 3
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer Director Rob Zombie on HALLOWEEN!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Bill Johnson, Leatherface From TEXAS CHAINSAW MASSACRE 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Vigdis Anholt From LITTLE ERIN MERRYWEATHER
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Italian Actress Coralina Cataldi-Tassoni
- ICONS INTERVIEW: David J Stieve, Writer Of BEHIND THE MASK
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Mike Mendez, Director of THE GRAVEDANCERS
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Eric Nicholas, Writer Director of ALONE WITH HER
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Natassia Malthe
- HELLGATE: A Crap Movie Discovery From Mike C.
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Dave Parker
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Rolfe Kanefsky
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker Christopher P. Garetano Interview 2!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Arrow In The Head’s John Fallon
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer Joe Harris, THE TRIPPER!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Producer / Director Tony Krantz
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Gordy Haab, Composer Of BEHIND THE MASK
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Nathan Baesel From BEHIND THE MASK: THE RISE OF LESLIE VERNON
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Scott Glosserman, Director Of BEHIND THE MASK
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker James Felix McKenney
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Director Bryan Norton
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Christie Sanford From SATAN’S PLAYGROUND
2006
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ryan Ward, Ash From EVIL DEAD: THE MUSICAL
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Kevin Kangas, Writer Director of FEAR OF CLOWNS 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ken Sagoes From A NIGHTMARE ON ELM STREET 3
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Judah Friedlander!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: SCREAM’s David Arquette!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ryan Schifrin, Writer Director of ABOMINABLE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: John Shiban, Director of REST STOP
- ICON INTERVIEW: JT Petty, Director S&MAN
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Nick Palumbo, Writer Director of MURDER SET PIECES
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Raine Brown
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer Director Filmmaker Gary Sherman
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Lin Shaye From 2001 MANIACS!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Christa Campbell From 2001 MANIACS!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor David Morwick From LITTLE ERIN MERRYWEATHER
- ICONS INTERVIEW: FX Artist Greg Nicotero of KNB!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Mark Pavia, Writer Director of NIGHT FLIER
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Comic Writer Steve Niles, Creator of 30 DAYS OF NIGHT
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Adam Green, Writer Director of HATCHET!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor / Filmmaker Joe Zaso
- ICONS INTERVIEW: James Wan, Director of SAW!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Liev Schreiber on THE OMEN!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Julia Stiles on THE OMEN!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Mia Farrow on THE OMEN!
- ICONS INTERVIEW: John Moore, Director of THE OMEN
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actress Wendy Kremer From 2001 MANIACS
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Mushmond Lee From 2001 MANIACS
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker David “Slave” Stagnari
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker Will Rot
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Tibor Takas, Director of THE GATE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Danny Lopes
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Oz Perkins
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker Steve Daniels
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker Composer Jake Hamilton
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Director Uwe Boll
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker Steven Shea
2005
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Paul Solet
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Don Shanks, Michael Myers In HALLOWEEN 5
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Paul Kratka From FRIDAY THE 13TH PART 3
- ICONS INTERVIEW: WE ALL FALL DOWN Writer / Director Jake Kennedy
- ICONS INTERVIEW: SIN-JIN SMYTH Writer / Director Ethan Dettenmaier
- ICONS INTERVIEW: THE RADIO MECHANICS Writer / Director Jonathan Johnson
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Interview 2 with Writer / Director Stevan Mena
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Interview 2 with Writer / Director Dante Tomaselli
- ICONS INTERVIEW: HORROR BUSINESS Director Christopher P. Garetano
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Adam Barnick
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Filmmaker / Horror Collector John Torrani
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Actor Joshua Nelson
- ICONS INTERVIEW: HALLOWEEN 6 Screenwriter Daniel Farrands
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Patricia Tallman From NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD 1990
- ICONS INTERVIEW: BLACK CHRISTMAS Director Bob Clark
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Edwin Neal From THE TEXAS CHAIN SAW MASSACRE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ben Chapman, The Gillman From CREATURE FROM THE BLACK LAGOON
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Brandon Johnson From MALEVOLENCE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Samantha Dark From MALEVOLENCE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Keith Chambers From MALEVOLENCE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Judith O’ Dea From NIGHT OF THE LIVING DEAD
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Paul Swearingen
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Lance Warlock From HALLOWEEN II
2004
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Diana Barrows From FRIDAY THE 13TH 7
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Brad Loree, Michael Myers in HALLOWEEN: RESURRECTION
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Burton C Bell of FEAR FACTORY
- ICONS INTERVIEW: PJ Soles From HALLOWEEN
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ellie Cornell From HALLOWEEN 4
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Stevan Mena, Writer & Director of MALEVOLENCE
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Felissa Rose, Angela From SLEEPAWAY CAMP
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ladies Of The EVIL DEAD
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Lar Park Lincoln From FRIDAY THE 13TH 7
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Ron Millkie From FRIDAY THE 13TH
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Warrington Gillette, Jason in FRIDAY THE 13TH PART 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Betsy Palmer From FRIDAY THE 13TH
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Larry Zerner From FRIDAY THE 13TH PART 3
- ICONS INTERVIEW: SLEEPAWAY CAMP Webmaster Jeff Hayes
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Tony Timpone from FANGORIA Magazine
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Actor Stu Charno from FRIDAY THE 13TH PART 2
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Writer / Director Dante Tomaselli
- ICONS INTERVIEW: Producer Anthony Masi